Critic Shelf
Home
Discover
Sign in
Your rating
Tap a star, half steps count

Sinister Secret Ingredient

Feb 27, 2026 · 1h 28m
No ratings yet
Thriller
Drama
TV Movie

PLOT

When dentist Mel buys a small-town clinic to start a new life, she meets Ruth, a beloved baker and neighbor with a tragic past. But when Mel’s 12-year-old daughter Abby goes missing, Mel uncovers Ruth’s horrifying secret.

REVIEWS

View reviews

CAST

Sabrina Miller
Mel
Ginger Gilmartin
Ruth
Justin Ross Martin
Nick
Gwen Mowdy
Abby
Barbara Sandlin
Barb
Ed Spinelli
The Neighbor
Betsy Hume
Janine
Ryan Francis
Robert
Directed by Tom Shell

DETAILS

Status
Released
Original language
EN
Budget
—
Revenue
—
Production
Studio TF1 America, Lifetime
Country
US
Critic Shelf
Rate what you watch, show it on shelves, and compare taste with anyone. Film and TV data from TMDB.
ACCOUNT
Sign in
Create account
Delete account
COMPANY
About
Contact
Privacy
Terms
This product uses TMDB and the TMDB APIs but is not endorsed, certified, or otherwise approved by TMDB.
© 2026 Critic Shelf
WATCH · RATE · COMPARE