Critic Shelf
Home
Discover
Sign in
Your rating
Tap a star, half steps count

Shall We Forgive Her?

Oct 15, 1917 · 50m
No ratings yet
Drama

PLOT

When Grace Raymond follows Neil Garth, her hard-drinking fiancé, West, she finds him living in a squalid desert cabin. Forced to choose between being raped by outlaws or giving in to Neil's sexual demands, Grace moves in with her fiancé. A year later, Grace rescues James Stapleton, a gold miner, from a desert death and helps him to escape from Neil's greedy clutches. Before Neil can punish her, she knocks him out and flees to New York, where she meets and then marries Oliver West, a jeweler with failing vision. To help with his medical bills, Grace sells a short story, but Neil shows up and threatens to expose her past unless she gives him her earnings. Eventually, Oliver finds out about Grace and Neil and goes blind from the shock. Determined to win Oliver back, Grace enlists the help of Stapleton, now a rich broker, to thwart Neil and secure a sight-restoring operation for Oliver. When Oliver hears Neil's confession of Grace's difficult past, he finally forgives her.

REVIEWS

View reviews

CAST

June Elvidge
Grace Raymond
Arthur Ashley
Neil Garth
John Bowers
Oliver West
Charles Clary
Uncle John
Herbert Barrington
Paul Ellsworth
Arthur Matthews
Dick
George MacQuarrie
James Stapleton
Alexandria Carewe
Joan
Directed by Arthur Ashley

DETAILS

Status
Released
Original language
EN
Budget
—
Revenue
—
Production
World Film
Country
US

SIMILAR TITLES

The Road of Ambition
1920
The Breath of Scandal
1924
The Puppets of Fate
1916
The Probation Wife
1919
The Isle of Conquest
1919
Carmen
1915
Critic Shelf
Rate what you watch, show it on shelves, and compare taste with anyone. Film and TV data from TMDB.
ACCOUNT
Sign in
Create account
Delete account
COMPANY
About
Contact
Privacy
Terms
This product uses TMDB and the TMDB APIs but is not endorsed, certified, or otherwise approved by TMDB.
© 2026 Critic Shelf
WATCH · RATE · COMPARE